Today

Today's published judgments

Migration
CYKF v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2026] FCA 1749
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – applicant’s application for adjournment of final hearing – where adjournment application opposed by the first respondent – consideration of s 37M of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) – whether within the interests of the administration of justice to vacate final hearing date – adjournment application dismissed – applicant provided extension of time to file any further amended application and submissions
9 Nov 2026 |  WIGNEY J


Migration
Parsons v Assistant Minister for Immigration [2026] FCA 1706
MIGRATION — application for judicial review of decision of Assistant Minister under s 501BA(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) to set aside decision of Administrative Review Tribunal and cancel applicant’s visa — whether the Assistant Minister’s decision was irrational, illogical or legally unreasonable — where Assistant Minister stated that no weight was given to applicant’s non-conviction offending and juvenile offending — where Assistant Minister referred to increasing seriousness of applicant’s offending history — whether Assistant Minister was prohibited by s 14 of the Children (Criminal Proceedings) Act 1987 (NSW) in combination with ss 85ZR and 85ZS of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) from considering applicant’s prior offending — where prior offending included offending as a juvenile in South Australia — where there is no South Australian equivalent to s 14 of the Children (Criminal Proceedings) Act 1987 (NSW) — where Assistant Minister not precluded from considering underlying conduct of applicant’s prior offending — where s 501M of the Migration Act permitted Assistant Minister to use criminal history information notwithstanding ss 85ZR and 85ZS of the Crimes Act — where Assistant Minister is not restricted in having regard to applicant’s criminal offending as a juvenile or adult — whether handwritten notation “has form” demonstrated impermissible reliance on prior offending — where authorship of notation not established — where notation is consistent with the applicant’s offending history — whether reference to increasing seriousness of offending history was incompatible with statement that no weight was given to prior offending — where prior offending used as comparator to identify trend of increasing seriousness rather than being attributed weight per se in favour of cancellation — no legal unreasonableness established — application dismissed
17 Nov 2026 |  O'SULLIVAN J


Representative Proceedings
Kusmanoff v Retail Employees Superannuation Pty Limited [2026] FCA 1728
REPRESENTATIVE PROCEEDINGS – notices – registration process – application by Respondent for an order that a notice be sent to group members foreshadowing an intention to seek an order that only registered group members can participate in any settlement – where Applicant opposed the application – where Applicant’s claims concern the automatic provision of income protection insurance to inactive superannuation fund members in particular circumstances – where the parties have no way of identifying which of the approximately 950,000 inactive members are group members – uncertainty as to group size, quantum, and settlement participation rates – where early resolution of the proceeding in the best interests of group members as a whole – where registration process would significantly enhance the prospect of settlement of the proceeding – application granted
17 Nov 2026 |  BUTTON J


Corporations
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Diamond Wheels Pty Ltd (Penalty Hearing) [2026] FCA 1734
CORPORATIONS – civil pecuniary penalties – corporate contraveners operated as constituent parts of an economically coordinated family business – capacity to pay – historical financial support from related entities – qualified findings of referee – distinction between economic interdependence and demonstrated access to resources – associated persons’ assets not attributed to corporate contraveners – appropriate corporate penalties determined at $2.5 million and $3.5 million CONSUMER LAW – admitted contraventions of the National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009 (Cth) and National Credit Code – provision of consumer credit and collection of repayments without an Australian credit licence – interest calculated on original loan amounts rather than unpaid daily balances – involvement of director in corporate contraventions PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – civil pecuniary penalties – general and specific deterrence – intended commercial advantage, actual receipts and net financial benefit – assessment of consumer harm – cooperation, admissions and remediation – civil double jeopardy, course of conduct, parity and totality – agreed penalty for individual contravener – rational relationship between individual and corporate penalties – agreed individual penalty of $750,000 approved CONSUMER LAW – statutory injunctions – protective purpose – restraints concerning existing contracts and unlicensed credit activity – proposed permanent restraint on individual’s participation in regulated consumer credit – good-faith but mistaken reliance on arrangements involving licence holder – scope and duration of restraint – five-year restraint appropriate
17 Nov 2026 |  LEE J


Contempt of Court
Goldmate Group Pty Ltd v Yang (Contempt) [2026] FCA 1733
CONTEMPT OF COURT – disobedience of freezing orders – knowledge of orders – borrowed funds applied to expenses of corporate liquidations – extended definition of assets – distinction between right to borrow and control of loan proceeds – funds held in third-party trust account – ordinary and proper course of business exception – inference concerning unencumbered value of Australian assets – proof beyond reasonable doubt – Charges 2 and 3 proved – penalty and consequential relief reserved CONTEMPT OF COURT – alleged failure to produce documents in answer to notice to produce – amendment of charge – distinction between notice to produce and order requiring production – coercive effect of notice under Rules – amended Charge 4 not established and dismissed PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – bankruptcy of respondent and liquidation of companies – statutory stay of substantive claims – Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) s 58(3)(b) – Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 471B – whether leave required to pursue contempt application – leave granted – documents produced on subpoena – claim of legal professional privilege – whether determination of claim necessary
17 Nov 2026 |  LEE J


Migration
Saha v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2026] FCA 1715
MIGRATION – appeal from dismissal of application for judicial review – refusal of student visa – genuine temporary entrant criterion – whether Tribunal failed to consider relevant evidence – delay in determination of merits review – procedural fairness – whether applicant afforded opportunity to address concern about continued residence in Australia – alleged tentative or speculative findings – benefit of proposed further study in applicant’s home country – reference to currency exchange rates – materiality of alleged error – appeal dismissed
17 Nov 2026 |  LEE J


Practice and Procedure
He v DC Rd DC Pty Ltd [2026] FCA 1746
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application to vary freezing orders to allow sale of property – application granted subject to conditions PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application to vary order for security for costs – insufficient evidence of material change in circumstances and lack of capacity to pay – issues with disclosure and candour with the Court in relation to the appellant’s financial position – application dismissed
11 Nov 2026 |  NESKOVCIN J


Corporations
Peet Limited, in the matter of Peet Limited [2026] FCA 1741
CORPORATIONS - scheme of arrangement – first court hearing - application under s 411(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) for company to convene a meeting to consider a scheme of arrangement – consideration of factors relevant to the exercise of Court's discretion to order a meeting – consideration of aspects of scheme that contemplate establishment of a joint venture between bidder and an associate of a shareholder in Peet to be known as Flagstone joint venture – orders made in terms sought for convening of shareholders' meeting – supplementary disclosure regularised by order
3 Nov 2026 |  COLVIN J


Corporations
Hammer Metals Limited, in the matter of Hammer Metals Limited (No 2) [2026] FCA 1743
CORPORATIONS – scheme of arrangement – application for approval of scheme under s 411(4)(b) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – acquisition of 100% of shares in plaintiff in exchange for shares in bidder – concurrent demerger of Western Australian gold assets from plaintiff by way of capital reduction and not scheme – scheme approved by necessary majorities of shareholders – orders made approving scheme
13 Nov 2026 |  JACKSON J


Practice and Procedure
Tuileapa v Suntory Beverage & Food Australia Pty Ltd [2026] FCA 1745
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – informal application for recusal– whether apprehended bias demonstrated – where plaintiff sought urgent hearing – where plaintiff sent voluminous correspondence to the Court – application dismissed
16 Nov 2026 |  MEAGHER J


Was this page useful?

What did you like about it?

If you would like the Court to contact you about your website feedback enter your email address in the box below. If you need help with a Court matter, visit the Contact Us pages or go to Live Chat.

How can we make it better?

If you would like the Court to contact you about your website feedback enter your email address in the box below. If you need help with a Court matter, visit the Contact Us pages or go to Live Chat.

* This online submission is protected by captcha